Amazon molly is a sexual parasite
All Amazon mollies are female. A female mates with a male of another species—and then gives birth to daughters that are clones of herself. What sustains this sexual parasitism? Waldir Berbel-Filho and colleagues solve a piece of the puzzle.
The tropical fish Poecilia formosa, the Amazon molly, has a peculiar sex life. The species consists only of females that reproduce asexually: they produce daughters that are genetic copies of the mothers. However, a female must mate with a male to initiate the development of the embryos. Since there are no males of their own species, she will mate with a male of a related species. His sperm triggers the development of her eggs, but his genetic material (DNA) is sidelined. He does not contribute to the genetic make-up of the offspring.
Amazons thus sexually parasitize males of other species. Researchers like Waldir Berbel-Filho and his colleagues are puzzled by how this situation can persist.
Hybrid
The Amazon molly is a freshwater fish averaging about 5.5 centimetres in length that lives in southern Texas and northeastern Mexico. The species is a hybrid, resulting from a single mating event of a male Poecilia latipinna (sailfin molly) and a female Poecilia mexicana (shortfin molly). These parental species are the ‘hosts’ on which the Amazones sexually parasitize.
Where Amazon mollies live, typically only one of the parent species is found, either the sailfin molly or the shortfin molly. The silvery-gray females of all three species look quite similar, but they differ in body shape: the shortfin molly is longer and thinner than the sailfin molly, and its shorter dorsal fin is inserted more posteriorly. Amazon mollies are intermediate in body shape between the two parental species, but their shape varies across locations.
Miracle
Hybridization occurred 100,000 to 200,000 years ago, meaning that the Amazon molly has gone through approximately 500,000 generations.
That’s a miracle. Because male sailfins and shortfins that mate with an Amazon do not sire any offspring, you’d expect them to learn to distinguish between an Amazon molly and a female of their own species and avoid mating with an Amazon molly. But if they would mate only with females of their own species, the Amazon molly can’t reproduce and becomes extinct.
In addition, the Amazon molly competes with its parental species for food; the fish mainly eat algae and small insects. And because Amazons only have daughters, their populations can grow twice as fast as those of the parental species, which produce equal numbers of sons and daughters. The Amazons could therefore displace the parental species, but then, due to a lack of males, they also perish.
Body shape
It seems like a hopeless situation. To explain why Amazon mollies still manage to survive, Berbel-Filho investigated three possibilities.
First possibility: to attract males, Amazons in each location most closely resemble females of the parental species that is present there. So, where they coexist with sailfin molly, they resemble female sailfin molly, and where they coexist with shortfin molly, they resemble female shortfin molly. In other words, they deceive males through mimicry.
Second possibility: to diminish competition for food, Amazon mollies differ from females of the parental species that they coexist with. If that parental species is sailfin molly, they resemble female shortfin mollies, and vice versa. The underlying idea is that a different body shape is associated with a slightly different diet, so that species with different body shapes at least have some of the available food for themselves, and the species can coexist.
Third possibility: the shape variation of Amazon mollies is random and independent of the parental species with which they occur.
Detailed measurements showed that the second possibility is correct. Amazon mollies are less similar in body shape to females of the parental species with which they coexist. The conclusion is that Amazons do not displace the locally present parent species through food competition, although it still needs to be proven that a difference in body shape indeed reduces competition for food.
Waste
But then there is the other danger: the danger that males of the parental species won’t mate with Amazons. The difference between females in each location helps males distinguish the sexual parasite from their own species. Previous research has shown that males indeed mate more often with females of their own species. So how does the Amazon molly manage to survive?
There is no clear answer to that yet. It could be, I think, because females differ on average. The fish vary in body shape, and there is some overlap between females of the local parental species and Amazons. If males were so choosy as to avoid any mating with an Amazon, they would also reject some females of their own species and miss out on paternity. If the amount of sperm they produce isn’t limiting, they’d be better off wasting some sperm to the wrong females than losing fertilisation opportunities with good ones.
Willy van Strien
Photo: Amazon molly, Poecilia formosa. ©Tyler Reich
Sources:
Berbel-Filho, W.M., M. Tobler, T. Reich, A. Eghbalpour, M.J. Ryan, K. Heubel, F. Garcia-De León & I. Schlupp, 2025. Converging or diverging? Shape coevolution between a sperm-dependent asexual and its sexual hosts. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 292: 20250432. Doi: 10.1098/rspb.2025.0432
Riesch, R., M. Plath, A.M. Makowicz & I. Schlupp. 2012. Behavioural and life-history regulation in a unisexual/bisexual mating system: does male mate choice affect female reproductive life histories? Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 106: 598-606. Doi: 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2012.01886.x
Riesch, R., I. Schlupp & M. Plath, 2008. Female sperm limitation in natural populations of a sexual/asexual mating complex (Poecilia latipinna, Poecilia formosa). Biology Letters 4: 266-269. Doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2008.0019